Favourite song from Season 2 (so far...)

1. Carol Brown
2. Epileptic Dog benefit song
3. Jemaine/prostitute

I'm changing my second favorite from Hurt Feelings to Too Many Dicks.

1. Too Many Dicks on the dance floor
2. Sugalumps
3. You Don't have to be a prostitute

Is it weird that every time I try to pick a favorite I fail? " title="" border="0"/> They're all special to me in different ways.

That's pretty much how I feel about the songs from S1. I could never choose a fave amongst them. But sadly many S2 songs are pretty lame so it was easy for me to sort the good from the bad.

Katie wrote:Is it weird that every time I try to pick a favorite I fail? " title="" border="0"/> They're all special to me in different ways.

I the music this season. The only songs I didn't love were Rejected and Carol Brown.

There were a few that seriously made me cringe. I think when the songs fail they fail big time. I also can't imagine that they will garner the same fanaticism that the old songs did. I wonder what the mix of songs is going to be like for the live shows?

SheWolf wrote:There were a few that seriously made me cringe. I think when the songs fail they fail big time. I also can't imagine that they will garner the same fanaticism that the old songs did. I wonder what the mix of songs is going to be like for the live shows?

With the exception of Rejected, I really like all of this season's songs as well. I'm not sure how some of them will translate to the live show, but in the context of the TV show I think they've been great.

Do you think they are as good as the S1 songs?

Katie wrote:

SheWolf wrote:There were a few that seriously made me cringe. I think when the songs fail they fail big time. I also can't imagine that they will garner the same fanaticism that the old songs did. I wonder what the mix of songs is going to be like for the live shows?

With the exception of Rejected, I really like all of this season's songs as well. I'm not sure how some of them will translate to the live show, but in the context of the TV show I think they've been great.

Why is everyone hating on Rejected?

SheWolf wrote:Do you think they are as good as the S1 songs?

I do.

thedistantfuture wrote:

Katie wrote:
With the exception of Rejected, I really like all of this season's songs as well. I'm not sure how some of them will translate to the live show, but in the context of the TV show I think they've been great.

Why is everyone hating on Rejected?

I Murray and I didn't hate Rejected... I just didn't like it that much.

blondesnotbombs wrote:

SheWolf wrote:Do you think they are as good as the S1 songs?

I do.

Me too. I think we had a lot of time to get used to the season 1 songs, and personally I think the season 2 songs will hold up just as well over time. Just my opinion though.

Katie wrote:

SheWolf wrote:There were a few that seriously made me cringe. I think when the songs fail they fail big time. I also can't imagine that they will garner the same fanaticism that the old songs did. I wonder what the mix of songs is going to be like for the live shows?

With the exception of Rejected, I really like all of this season's songs as well. I'm not sure how some of them will translate to the live show, but in the context of the TV show I think they've been great.

I've loved (or at least really liked) all the songs this season. I even like Rejected. ;
) Maybe part of it is because I was desparate for some new FOTC material, but probably the main reason is that the songs have just been awesome.

Demon Woman is my new fav.

thedistantfuture wrote:Demon Woman is my new fav.

You must've read the music geek thread! (kidding ;
))

gezyka wrote:

thedistantfuture wrote:Demon Woman is my new fav.

You must've read the music geek thread! (kidding ;
))

No,I haven't yet actually.

I just really love how it's more rock-ish than a lot of their other stuff. And it sounds kind of 70's-ish.

sugalumps
too many dicks
demon woman
you don't have to be a prostitute
hurt feelings
choir of ex-girlfriends (i doubt the official title is "
carol brown"
)

but let's see, if i have to pick only 2...

hurt feelings and sugalumps

I love all the songs except I dislike but still like (if that makes sense) Rejected and Love is a Weapon of Choice. Other than that I really think all the songs have been perfect.

The more I listen to We're Both In Love With A Sexy Lady the more I love it. I can't get enough and Jem's vocals in that song are teh sex.

My favourite is still Hurt Feelings then in no particular order: Sugalumps, Too Many Dicks, Sexy Lady, You Don't Have To Be A Prostitute, Demon Woman and Carol Brown.

duttle wrote:choir of ex-girlfriends (i doubt the official title is "
carol brown"
)

They've been calling it Carol Brown since the beginning. And it's the name on the itunes download which I thought made it pretty "
official"
.

oh. i didn't know about the itunes release.

F-F-F-F-F-F-FASHION.

tickertapequeen wrote:F-F-F-F-F-F-FASHION.

So does that push Prostitute down to your second choice now then?

Anyone else need an update?

sargifster wrote:

tickertapequeen wrote:F-F-F-F-F-F-FASHION.

So does that push Prostitute down to your second choice now then?

Anyone else need an update?

Yup! Thanks

There's been an upset in my list of favorites! My revised top three:

1. Bret's Day (I guess that's what we're calling it)
2. Hurt Feelings (Reprise)
3. Friends